Quick answer: A prepayment penalty is a fee for paying a DSCR loan off early — by sale, refinance, or a large paydown — inside a window at the start of the loan. The common shape is a step-down: under a 5/4/3/2/1 structure, a payoff in year one costs 5% of the balance repaid, falling one point a year until it disappears after year five. Three-year (3/2/1) and flat structures are also common. Programs usually offer a shorter window or none at all, and the trade is made in the loan's pricing. The decision turns on one thing: how long you will really hold the property.
Not sure which structure fits your plan?
Ten minutes with a Las Vegas loan officer: your realistic hold period, and what each structure would mean on your file. No obligation, no charge.
Get My QuoteThis is the term investors most often agree to without reading, and the one most likely to cost them real money. A prepayment penalty does nothing at all — until the day you want out. Then it is a line on a settlement statement that can swallow a chunk of the gain you were counting on. The structure is not a trap in itself; it is a legitimate trade. It only becomes a trap when the loan's exit window and the investor's actual plan were never compared.
Key takeaways
- It is an exit cost, not a monthly one. It never appears in your payment and never enters the DSCR ratio.
- Step-down is the common shape. 5/4/3/2/1 means 5% of the balance repaid in year one, declining a point a year to nothing after year five. 3/2/1 and flat structures also appear.
- The percentages are of loan balance, not interest. Confusing the two is the single most common misreading of this term.
- Shorter or zero-penalty versions usually exist, and the difference is made up in the loan's pricing. Ask for both on your own file rather than trusting a published figure.
- Sale carve-outs are program-specific. Some waive the penalty on a genuine sale but charge it on a refinance. Never assume it.
- It exists because this is business-purpose credit. Regulation Z restricts prepayment penalties on consumer mortgages at 12 CFR 1026.43(g); a genuine investment-property loan is exempt under 12 CFR 1026.3(a)(1).
What a prepayment penalty is, and when it bites
A prepayment penalty is a fee charged when you repay the loan early, inside a window that starts at closing. Three events typically trigger it: selling the property, refinancing it, or paying the balance down by more than the loan allows in a year.
What makes it easy to ignore is that it does nothing in the meantime. It is not in your payment. It is not in the DSCR calculation — that is still gross rent over PITIA, and you can run it on our DSCR loan calculator without reference to the penalty at all. It sits dormant until the moment you want to move, which is precisely why it is so often discovered late.
It appears on these loans and not on the mortgage for your own home because the two are different legal products. Regulation Z restricts prepayment penalties on consumer mortgages at 12 CFR 1026.43(g). A genuine business-purpose investment loan is exempt from Regulation Z under 12 CFR 1026.3(a)(1) — the same exemption that lets the loan be underwritten to the property, and lets it sit in an LLC.
The structures you will be offered
Three shapes cover most of what appears on a term sheet.
| Structure | How it behaves | Cost of a year-one payoff |
|---|---|---|
| Five-year step-down (5/4/3/2/1) | Declines one point a year, gone after year five | 5% of the balance repaid |
| Three-year step-down (3/2/1) | Declines one point a year, gone after year three | 3% of the balance repaid |
| Flat (e.g. 3% for 3 years) | Same percentage every year of the window, then nothing | 3% of the balance repaid |
| None | No penalty at any point | Nothing |
Read the percentages carefully: they are percentages of the loan balance being repaid. A 5 in a step-down is not an interest rate, and treating it as one will lead you to a wildly wrong conclusion in both directions.
Working the exit cost
The arithmetic is simple once the term is read correctly. Take the balance you would repay, multiply by the penalty percentage for the year you would repay it.
Illustratively: on a $300,000 balance under a 5/4/3/2/1 step-down, exiting in year one costs $15,000; year two $12,000; year three $9,000; year four $6,000; year five $3,000; after that, nothing. Under a 3/2/1 the same exits cost $9,000, $6,000 and $3,000, then nothing from year four.
These are illustrative figures on a round balance, chosen to show the mechanics. Your balance, your structure and your timing will differ.
Now put that number where it belongs: next to the gain you expect from the exit. A refinance that pulls cash out in year two has to clear the year-two penalty before it is worth doing. A sale in year one has to clear the year-one penalty on top of commission and closing costs. Neither is automatically a bad idea — but neither should be planned without the number in front of you.
The trade you are actually making
A prepayment penalty is not a fee for nothing. Accepting one is generally reflected in the loan's pricing, and declining one is generally reflected the other way. We do not publish those figures here, and you should be sceptical of anyone who publishes them as though they were fixed — they move by lender, by day and by borrower profile. Ask for both structures on your own file and compare the actual numbers.
What we can give you is the decision rule, which does not change:
- If you will genuinely hold past the window, accepting a penalty is a reasonable trade. The cost never materialises, and you keep the pricing benefit for the whole hold.
- If there is a realistic chance you exit inside the window, treat the penalty as a probable cost, not a hypothetical one, and weigh it against what the shorter structure costs up front.
- If your plan depends on refinancing early — a renovation-then-refinance strategy, for instance — a long penalty window and that plan are in direct conflict. Resolve it before closing, not after.
The honest version of the question is not "which structure is cheaper?" It is "which is cheaper given what I will actually do?" Investors who answer the first question and act on it are the ones who get surprised.
Why this matters particularly in Las Vegas
Two local realities make the hold-period question sharper here than the generic advice suggests.
Short-term rental rules are unsettled. Clark County's licensing position has been through litigation, and an investor whose plan depends on operating a property as a short-term rental may find the plan has to change. A forced change of strategy often means a sale or a refinance — exactly the events a penalty window catches. We keep the current picture on the short-term rental DSCR page, and it is worth reading before you accept a five-year window on an STR thesis.
Property taxes reprice on a change of occupancy. Nevada caps annual increases at 3% for an owner's primary residence and up to 8% for residences that are not owner-occupied, with a rental able to reach the 3% cap where the rent charged does not exceed HUD's published fair market rent for the county, less utilities. An investor who budgeted from the seller's old capped bill can find the property's economics shift after purchase — and a property that no longer works the way it was underwritten is a property someone wants to exit.
Neither argues for or against a penalty. Both argue for being honest about how firm your hold period really is.
Questions to ask before you sign
- What is the exact structure — step-down or flat — and how many years?
- Is the percentage applied to the balance repaid, or to the original loan amount?
- Is there a carve-out for a genuine arm's-length sale, or does it apply to any payoff?
- How much principal may I pay down each year without triggering it?
- What would the same file look like with a shorter window, and with none?
- Is the penalty enforceable in the state where the property sits?
Get the answers in writing on the term sheet. "The lender usually waives that" is not an answer.
DSCR prepayment penalties: FAQ
What is a prepayment penalty on a DSCR loan?
It is a fee charged if you pay the loan off early — by selling, by refinancing, or by paying the balance down beyond an allowed amount — within a defined window at the start of the loan. It exists because these are business-purpose investment loans rather than consumer mortgages, and the investors who buy them price them expecting the loan to stay outstanding for a period.
What does a 5/4/3/2/1 step-down mean?
It describes how the penalty shrinks each year. Under a five-year step-down, paying the loan off in year one costs 5% of the balance being repaid, year two 4%, year three 3%, year four 2%, year five 1%, and nothing after that. Those figures are percentages of the loan balance, not interest rates. Three-year step-downs (3/2/1) and flat structures — the same percentage for every year of the window — are also common.
Can I get a DSCR loan with no prepayment penalty?
Often, yes. Programs commonly offer a version with a shorter penalty window or none at all, and the trade is made in the loan's pricing. We do not publish pricing on this page, and any figure you see quoted elsewhere is that lender's, on that day, for that borrower profile. The right way to evaluate it is to ask for both structures on your actual file and compare them.
Does the penalty apply if I sell the property?
It depends on the structure. Some carry a sale carve-out that waives the penalty on a genuine arm's-length sale while still charging it on a refinance; others apply to any payoff. This is a specific question to ask about a specific program — it is not a market-wide convention, and assuming the carve-out exists is an expensive way to find out it does not.
How do I decide which structure to take?
Start from your actual hold period, not your preferred one. If you genuinely intend to hold the property beyond the penalty window, accepting a penalty is a reasonable trade because the cost never materialises. If there is a realistic chance you sell or refinance inside the window, price the penalty as a real cost of that exit and compare it against what the shorter structure costs you up front. The honest question is not which is cheaper, but which is cheaper given what you will actually do.
Is a prepayment penalty legal on an investment loan?
Prepayment penalties are restricted on consumer mortgages, and the Regulation Z limits at 12 CFR 1026.43(g) are part of why borrowers rarely meet them on a primary residence. A genuine business-purpose investment loan is exempt from Regulation Z under 12 CFR 1026.3(a)(1), which is why the structure appears here and not on the loan for the house you live in.
Does a prepayment penalty affect my DSCR ratio?
No. The ratio is gross monthly rent divided by PITIA, and a prepayment penalty is an exit cost rather than a monthly one, so it never enters the calculation. It belongs in your hold-period and return analysis instead. You can run the ratio itself on our DSCR loan calculator.
The bottom line
A prepayment penalty is a legitimate structural trade, not a gotcha — but it is only a good trade if the penalty window and your real hold period were compared before closing. Read the percentages as percentages of balance, work the exit cost on your own number, and ask what the file looks like without the penalty before you decide.
If you are choosing between structures on a specific property, tell us about it and a Las Vegas loan officer will lay both out against your hold period. The rest of the file — credit, reserves, leverage — is on the DSCR loan requirements page. Valley West Mortgage is a mortgage lender, NMLS #65506. Equal Housing Opportunity.
